How to study return measures used in private equity
A family office executive Richard C. Wilson interviewed described three levels for choosing fund managers.[1]The first level is a statistical screen based mainly on measures of risk and measures of return.[1]The executive explained that a manager sitting in the fourth quartile is not likely to be hired.[1]A quantitative analysis of the manager comes after the screen.[1]This shows how return measures work as a filter before deeper review begins.[1]Another family office executive Richard C. Wilson interviewed described a formal investment committee that meets monthly with a regular agenda.[1]The fund investment department prepares due diligence packages and recommendations on fund managers.[1]The same department covers redemptions and any need to change managers in a strategy.[1]In a separate interview, a family office executive Richard C. Wilson interviewed said the committee often hears from client facing people, research people, and an overall strategist.[1]
See how debt and structure shape a return
Richard C. Wilson writes that the focus of direct investing is equity that is not publicly traded.[2]That leaves out the standard investments families make through mutual funds and traditional equity portfolios.[2]In direct investments, family offices will typically buy a large stake in a corporation and expect the equity value to rise over time.[2]Other times, a family office may act like a private equity investor and buy out an entire firm.[2]Richard C. Wilson notes that these complete buyouts are typically financed with debt.[2]The aim is to increase the return on investment and reduce the equity at stake in any one buyout.[2]The family still contributes a sizable equity slice, much as private equity funds do in their own buyouts financed with debt.[2]For a student, the lesson is that a return figure depends on how much equity sits behind it.[2]
Look at fees, terms and coinvestment
Coinvestment is another place where cost and return meet.[4]An investor commits capital to a fund as a traditional limited partner and also keeps the right to invest directly alongside the fund.[2]That gives the investor two stakes in the company, one through the fund and one directly.[2]In one example, a fund takes a company private for $10 billion and carves out a $500 million piece for a single family office.[4]Richard C. Wilson writes that limited partners hope to use coinvestments to reduce overall fees on private equity investments.[4]General partners have often resisted.[4]Their reasons include added complexity, capital that would have gone through the fund, more requests from other limited partners, and encouragement of future direct investments.[4]During the boom of 2006 and 2007, many general partners routinely dismissed requests for lower fees.[4]Later, investors held more power in negotiating terms, fees, and structure.[4]Family offices also look for exclusive access to deals, preferred terms, discounted management fees, or ownership stakes.[1]Richard C. Wilson writes that the amount of capital a family office controls is often its competitive advantage.[1]
Keep checking after the investment is made
Direct investing comes with the risk and responsibility of deep due diligence and ongoing monitoring.[2]Richard C. Wilson describes due diligence as a process that checks that a fund manager or investment fits the family mandate and meets the criteria of the family and its chief investment officer.[3]It helps avoid frauds, underperforming fund managers, and poorly structured investment banking deals.[3]Monitoring covers direct investments, real estate, and private equity funds as part of total portfolio monitoring.[3]Direct investments rarely need daily attention, unless the family office has a Chief Direct Investment Officer.[3]
Steps you can take
- Write down the measures of risk and return used to screen fund managers.
- Compare each manager against peers before starting deeper review.
- Note how much equity and how much debt sit behind any stated return.
- List the fees and terms of each fund and ask about coinvestment rights.
- Set a regular committee agenda with a due diligence package for each manager.
- Track direct investments, real estate, and private equity funds as part of total portfolio monitoring.
In direct investments, family offices will typically buy a large stake in a corporation with the expectation that the equity value will appreciate over time.
Questions people ask next
What do family offices look at first when screening fund managers?
A family office executive Richard C. Wilson interviewed described a statistical screen based mainly on measures of risk and measures of return.[1]A quantitative analysis of the manager follows.[1]
Why do investors ask for coinvestment rights?
Richard C. Wilson writes that limited partners hope to use coinvestments to reduce overall fees on private equity investments.[4]The investor also keeps the right to invest directly alongside the fund.[2]
Why is debt used in buyouts?
Richard C. Wilson writes that complete buyouts are typically financed with debt to increase the return on investment and reduce the equity at stake in any one buyout.[2]
Sources
- Richard C. Wilson, Family Office book (Wiley)
- Richard C. Wilson, The Single Family Office
- Richard C. Wilson, How to Start a Family Office
- Richard C. Wilson, The Single Family Office (Direct Investments edition)
Related pages
- How do family offices study the history of private equity?
- Types of private equity study map
- How to keep a personal study notebook for private equity work
- What is the investor side of a private equity fund?
- What is an investment period in a private equity fund?
Educational content only. Not investment, tax, legal or securities advice. Quotes are verbatim from Richard C. Wilson's own writing, as named in each Sources list. Talk with securities counsel before any offering is made.