Text or WhatsApp (808) 600-9260Richard@FamilyOffices.com

What history family offices review before a private equity commitment

Richard C. Wilson describes due diligence as a process aimed at ensuring that any fund manager selected or investment made fits within the family mandate.[1]The same process is meant to avoid frauds, underperforming fund managers, and wild goose chases after poorly structured investment banking deals.[1]Monitoring direct investments, real estate and private equity funds is also part of total portfolio monitoring.[1]Direct investments rarely need daily attention, unless the family office has employed a Chief Direct Investment Officer.[1]Richard C. Wilson also writes that direct investing comes with the risk and responsibility of deep due diligence and ongoing monitoring of the portfolio.[3]He lists speaking with other family offices and investors who have similar portfolios and challenges as part of the work.[1]

How a manager has behaved over time

In the fund manager selection process Richard C. Wilson describes, analysts, investment committee members, or the chief investment officer of a family office often hold a phone call with the manager.[2]They may ask tough questions about style drift.[2]They may ask what happened when a key executive left the team.[2]They may also ask how, why, and for how long the manager went to cash in the last recession.[2]These calls help investors sense where a manager is strong and where it is weak.[2]They also show where more research and data will be needed.[2]

What the due diligence questionnaire adds

Another step is a due diligence questionnaire, often called a DDQ.[2]These questionnaires consist of 30 to 180 questions.[2]Once the fund manager completes one, it can often run 50 to over 100 pages.[2]The point is to dig into the granular details of the fund's operations, legal structure, compensation structure, portfolio of investments, and future plans for growth.[2]Combined with the PowerPoint, the one pager, and the phone call, the DDQ is the bulk of what many analysts and investment committees use to review fund managers.[2]A family office executive Richard C. Wilson interviewed described a formal investment committee that meets monthly with a regular agenda.[2]The fund investment department there puts together due diligence packages and recommendations on fund managers.[2]It also covers any redemption and any need to change fund managers in a strategy.[2]

The history of terms between managers and investors

Richard C. Wilson writes that at the height of the boom in 2006 and 2007, many hedge funds and private equity firms were loath to accommodate even large institutional investors.[4]General partners routinely dismissed requests for improved terms, lower fees, and greater flexibility.[4]After weak results, with many funds collapsing or recording double digit losses, funds were vulnerable and eager to woo limited partners.[4]Many general partners then reconsidered, since investors held a stronger position in negotiating terms, fees, and structure.[4]Co-investment rights are one concession that managers offered to institutional investors as an inducement for committing capital to a fund.[3]By offering them, a general partner can often persuade reticent investors to allocate to a fund.[3]The investor commits as a traditional limited partner and also keeps the right to co-invest directly alongside the fund.[3]Richard C. Wilson writes that general partners resisted for several reasons, including added complexity and the chance that other limited partners ask for similar arrangements.[4]Family offices and other investors want these rights in part to reduce overall fees on private equity investments.[4]Richard C. Wilson also teaches that family offices often like exclusive access to deals, preferred terms, discounted management fees, or ownership stakes.[2]He describes the amount of capital a family office controls as its competitive advantage in many cases.[2]For private equity real estate funds, he notes that the general partner often charges a 2% management fee and a 20% performance fee, like private equity funds.[3]

Steps you can take

  1. Write down the family mandate before reading any fund materials.
  2. List the questions about style drift, key executive departures, and past recessions that you want to ask a manager.
  3. Read the due diligence questionnaire for operations, legal structure, compensation structure, and portfolio details.
  4. Compare the fund materials with the PowerPoint, one pager, and phone call notes.
  5. Note which terms, fees, and co-investment rights the manager has offered other investors.
  6. Bring the due diligence package to the investment committee for discussion.
  7. Talk with other family offices that face similar portfolio challenges.

This is critical to avoid frauds, underperforming fund managers and wild goose chases running after poorly structured investment banking deals.

Richard C. Wilson, How to Start a Family Office[1]

Questions people ask next

What is a due diligence questionnaire?

A DDQ is a set of 30 to 180 questions that digs into a fund's operations, legal structure, compensation structure, portfolio, and future plans.[2]Completed, it can often run 50 to over 100 pages.[2]

Why do family offices ask about a manager's past recession behavior?

Richard C. Wilson describes questions about how, why, and for how long a manager went to cash in the last recession.[2]Such questions help investors see a manager's strengths and weaknesses.[2]

What are co-investment rights?

They let an investor commit to a fund as a traditional limited partner and also invest directly alongside the fund.[3]Richard C. Wilson writes that managers have offered them as an inducement for committing capital.[3]

Sources
  1. Richard C. Wilson, How to Start a Family Office
  2. Richard C. Wilson, Family Office book (Wiley)
  3. Richard C. Wilson, The Single Family Office
  4. Richard C. Wilson, The Single Family Office (Direct Investments edition)

Related pages

Educational content only. Not investment, tax, legal or securities advice. Quotes are verbatim from Richard C. Wilson's own writing, as named in each Sources list. Talk with securities counsel before any offering is made.