How family offices review a first-time fund
Richard C. Wilson writes that a single wrong pick of a fund manager can be very costly.[1]He explains that a poor choice could lead to principal loss, capital locked up without need, low tax efficiency for a strategy, a bad reputation, regulatory action, or even civil and criminal liability.[1]Family offices have a fiduciary duty to complete due diligence on fund managers and to select them with care.[1]Wilson adds that the consequences of the choice, good or bad, are large.[1]That is part of why he calls family office expertise so important.[1]He also notes that investing directly comes with the risk and responsibility of deep due diligence and of monitoring the investment portfolio.[3]
A common six step process
Wilson describes the typical family office process for selecting a fund manager as six macro steps.[1]Larger institutions sometimes add sub steps.[1]He presents this as a collective view of what the industry uses at a high level and not as a recommended process.[1]The first step is typically a review of the one pager, also called a tear sheet, for a fund.[1]Early screening matters because it saves effort later. In Centimillionaire Strategies, Wilson writes that first round screening details can weed out 80% or more of the deals pitched to a family.[4]He says a head of direct investments, an analyst, or a portfolio manager can take a first cut.[4]In How to Start a Family Office, he describes having junior analysts screen the promising deals.[2]He also writes that high level criteria, customized for a team, save time and money in due diligence fees, travel, and team resources.[4]
Due diligence and the family mandate
Wilson describes in depth due diligence as a process that checks whether any fund manager selected, or any investment made, fits within the family mandate.[2]The same process checks the criteria of the family and its CIO.[2]He says this helps avoid frauds, underperforming fund managers, and wild goose chases after poorly structured investment banking deals.[2]He also gives an example of a family that spreads direct investments across many industries.[4]Due diligence is hard for that family because it is difficult to find an expert for each area or to learn what the checklist should even be.[4]The family ends up using a generic due diligence consulting firm.[4]Review does not end at the decision. Wilson writes that monitoring direct investments, real estate, and private equity funds is part of total portfolio monitoring.[2]He adds that direct investments rarely need daily attention unless the family office has a Chief Direct Investment Officer.[2]He also writes that the portfolio dictates how often an investment committee meets and what it discusses.[2]To plan this, he asks which areas the family invests in, how often each area needs review, and which team members are essential decision makers.[2]
How family offices work with fund managers
Wilson writes that family offices work with fund managers in many ways beyond direct investments.[1]Family offices often use the capital they control to seek exclusive access to deals, preferred terms, discounted management fees, or ownership stakes in some investments.[1]He says the amount of capital they control is many times their competitive advantage.[1]One example he teaches is partnering with a seed capital platform or giving seed capital directly to managers who have a great team and investment process.[1]Wilson also explains coinvestment. A limited partner invests directly with a general partner in a company, so capital goes to the company through the fund and also directly.[5]An investor allocates capital alongside a fund to a target investment rather than through the fund.[3]
Steps you can take
- Write down the family mandate and the criteria of the family and CIO before reading any fund materials.
- Begin with the one pager or tear sheet of the fund.
- Set high level filters and customize them for your team to screen out poor fits early.
- Ask an analyst or portfolio manager to take the first cut.
- Build a due diligence checklist for each strategy before paying for outside help.
- List which team members make decisions for each investment area and how often it needs review.
- Keep monitoring the fund as part of total portfolio monitoring after the investment is made.
This is critical to avoid frauds, underperforming fund managers and wild goose chases running after poorly structured investment banking deals.
Questions people ask next
What is a tear sheet?
Wilson describes the one pager, also called a tear sheet, as the document family offices typically review first in the fund manager selection process.[1]
Why do family offices run due diligence on fund managers?
Wilson writes that family offices have a fiduciary duty to complete due diligence on fund managers and to select them with care.[1]He also notes that one wrong choice can be very costly.[1]
What is coinvesting?
Wilson describes it as an investor allocating capital alongside an investment fund to a target investment rather than through the fund.[3]
Sources
- Richard C. Wilson, Family Office book (Wiley)
- Richard C. Wilson, How to Start a Family Office
- Richard C. Wilson, The Single Family Office
- Richard C. Wilson, Centimillionaire Strategies
- Richard C. Wilson, The Single Family Office (Direct Investments edition)
Related pages
- How fees and alignment come up when family offices review a fund
- How do family offices manage a portfolio over time?
- What is a first-time fund from an investor's chair?
- Why do family offices separate direct deals from fund commitments?
- How do family offices review company management in a deal?
Educational content only. Not investment, tax, legal or securities advice. Quotes are verbatim from Richard C. Wilson's own writing, as named in each Sources list. Talk with securities counsel before any offering is made.