How family offices compare a fund commitment with a direct investment
A fund commitment makes the family office a limited partner in the fund. The fund then invests in portfolio companies. A co-investment adds a direct position alongside the fund in a company, so the investor has exposure through both routes.[1][2]Wilson describes co-investing as an allocation alongside a fund to a target investment, rather than only through the fund. The fund manager or general partner may offer co-investment rights as part of a fund commitment. This lets an investor commit to the fund and retain the right to invest directly alongside it.[1][2]The comparison is therefore between a fund allocation and a direct position connected to a fund investment. A co-investment can be sourced by the general partner or lead investor. Wilson distinguishes this from a club deal, where active investors join as a consortium.[2]
Compare fees, terms, and structure
Wilson writes that family offices and other investors may seek co-investments to reduce overall fees on private equity investments and manage more investments internally. He also describes fund managers offering co-investment rights to encourage investors to commit to a fund.[1][2]A family office may also work with a fund manager to seek access to deals, preferred terms, discounted management fees, or ownership stakes in investments. The amount of capital under family office control can be used in discussions with fund managers.[3]The structure has costs for the fund manager as well as potential benefits for the investor. Wilson lists added complexity, capital moving from the standard fund vehicle into a co-investment, and the prospect that other limited partners will request similar arrangements. He also notes that co-investments can encourage future co-investments and direct investments by investors.[2]
Test the fit and the work required
Wilson describes due diligence as a process for checking whether a fund manager or investment fits the family mandate and meets the family’s and chief investment officer’s criteria. That work can apply to a fund commitment or a direct investment.[1][4]A direct investment brings responsibility for deep due diligence and ongoing portfolio maintenance and monitoring. Wilson writes that the degree of monitoring varies with the family office’s involvement, and that direct investments rarely require daily attention unless the office has a chief direct investment officer covering that area.[1]Fund manager diligence can also require time and resources. Wilson describes family offices as sometimes stretched thin when evaluating global managers, and notes that some use consulting firms to help evaluate managers and conduct on-site visits.[3]
Make the decision within the family process
A practical comparison considers the family mandate, the investment criteria, the fee and term structure, the diligence workload, and the monitoring required after investing. Wilson’s teaching treats due diligence and portfolio monitoring as parts of the family office’s broader investment work.[2][1]Family offices may prepare diligence packages and recommendations for an investment committee to discuss and decide. One family office executive Richard C. Wilson interviewed described a formal committee process that reviewed fund manager recommendations and changes to fund managers.[3]The choice between a fund commitment and a direct position can be considered in that same decision process. For legal, tax, and securities questions tied to a particular arrangement, family offices often talk with securities counsel and relevant professional advisors.[1]
Steps you can take
- Write down the family mandate and the criteria the investment must meet.
- Map the fund commitment and any direct co-investment as separate positions.
- Compare the fees, terms, and structure for each route.
- List the diligence work needed for the fund manager and the company.
- Estimate the internal time needed to maintain and monitor each position.
- Prepare the comparison for the family office decision process.
- Talk with securities counsel about legal and securities questions for the arrangement.
A common scenario that illustrates this distinction is when a private equity fund grants co-investment rights to a single family office.
Questions people ask next
What is the difference between a fund commitment and a co-investment?
A fund commitment allocates capital through the fund as a limited partner. A co-investment places capital directly alongside the fund in a target company, giving the investor exposure through both routes.[1][2]
Why might a family office consider co-investing?
Wilson writes that investors may seek co-investments to reduce overall private equity fees and manage more investments internally. Fund managers may offer co-investment rights to encourage an investor to commit to a fund.[1][2]
What work does a direct investment require?
Wilson connects direct investing with deep due diligence, portfolio maintenance, and monitoring. The amount of monitoring varies, and direct investments rarely require daily attention unless a family office has a chief direct investment officer covering them.[1]
Sources
- Richard C. Wilson, The Single Family Office
- Richard C. Wilson, The Single Family Office (Direct Investments edition)
- Richard C. Wilson, Family Office book (Wiley)
- Richard C. Wilson, How to Start a Family Office
Related pages
- Why do family offices separate direct deals from fund commitments?
- How family offices document diligence on a fund or a direct deal
- How do family offices run due diligence on direct deals?
- How do family offices build an investment policy?
- How do family offices source direct investments?
Educational content only. Not investment, tax, legal or securities advice. Quotes are verbatim from Richard C. Wilson's own writing, as named in each Sources list. Talk with securities counsel before any offering is made.