Text or WhatsApp (808) 600-9260Richard@FamilyOffices.com

How exits work in direct and fund private equity

The Single Family Office includes a quoted passage on selling. It says an asset is generally sold when it has greater value to a buyer[1]. This often happens when a buyer has a complementary business or capability that lets them do more with that business[1]. The same passage says many businesses that were exited were not failures[1]. They had reached a point in their life cycle where they no longer provided a core capability or served as a platform for growth[1]. So a sale can follow a business that simply reached a new stage, and not only one that struggled[1]. The chapter pairs this with a second idea, that the danger lies in failing to evolve[1]. Read together, the two ideas treat an exit as a normal part of managing a portfolio over time[1].

Fund stakes and direct stakes

In a fund, an investor commits capital as a traditional limited partner[1]. That capital reaches the company through the fund and not directly[2]. Direct investing comes with the risk and responsibility of deep due diligence and of maintaining and monitoring the investment portfolio[1]. Wilson defines coinvestment as an investor, often an institutional investor with substantial investable capital, putting money into a company alongside a fund rather than through it[2]. He gives a scenario in which a fund takes a company private for $10 billion and carves out $500 million for a single family office to invest directly alongside the fund[2]. In that case the investor holds two stakes in the company, one through the fund and one directly[1][2]. Coinvestment rights are one of the concessions fund managers offer to institutional investors as an inducement to commit capital to a fund[1][2]. Because the investor keeps the right to invest directly alongside the fund, a holder of both kinds of stake has two interests to track, one held through the fund and one held directly[1][2].

Why fund managers and investors see coinvestment differently

Wilson lists reasons general partners have resisted coinvestment rights[2]. The coinvestment adds a layer of complexity to the fund[2]. The general partner gives up capital that would have been invested under the standard fund vehicle[2]. Other limited partners are more likely to ask for similar arrangements[2]. Allowing coinvestments also encourages future coinvestments and direct investments by investors[2]. Family offices and other investors want these rights for many of the same reasons[2]. Limited partners hope to use coinvestments to reduce overall fees on private equity investments and to manage more investments internally[2]. Wilson also describes a period when many general partners reconsidered earlier resistance because investors had greater room to negotiate terms, fees, and structure[2]. Family offices also like to seek exclusive access to deals, preferred terms, discounted management fees, or ownership stakes in some of their investments[3]. Wilson writes that the amount of capital a family office controls is often its competitive advantage[3].

The work around an exit decision

Wilson describes in depth due diligence as a process aimed at making sure any fund manager selected or investment made fits the family mandate and meets the criteria of the family and the chief investment officer[4]. He says this work helps avoid frauds, underperforming fund managers, and poorly structured investment banking deals[4]. Monitoring is part of the same work. Monitoring direct investments, real estate, and private equity funds is a component of total portfolio monitoring[4]. Direct investments rarely require daily attention unless the family office has employed a Chief Direct Investment Officer[4]. Wilson also notes that outsourced Chief Direct Investment Officer services are being offered to single family offices to help with coinvestments, club deals, and direct investments into operating businesses[1]. As family offices seek more direct investments, the need for talented professionals who can head up that activity is growing[1]. He adds that fund manager selection can finish in 2 to 4 months, but most selections take at least 6 to 12 months[3].

Steps you can take

  1. Write down which of your interests are held through a fund and which are held directly.
  2. Read the coinvestment terms for each company where you hold both kinds of stake.
  3. Ask whether a buyer with a complementary business or capability could get more from the asset.
  4. Check whether the asset has reached a point in its life cycle where it no longer serves as a platform for growth.
  5. Keep due diligence and monitoring records current for every direct investment.
  6. Decide who on the team covers direct investing activity, such as a Chief Direct Investment Officer.

Questions people ask next

What is coinvestment?

Wilson defines it as an investor allocating capital alongside an investment fund to a target company, rather than only through the fund[2]. The investor can then hold one stake through the fund and another directly[1].

Why have fund managers resisted coinvestment rights?

Wilson lists added complexity, capital that moves outside the standard fund vehicle, more requests from other limited partners, and more future direct investing by investors[2].

When is an asset generally sold?

The quoted passage says an asset is generally sold when it has greater value to a buyer, often because the buyer has a complementary business or capability.

Sources
  1. Richard C. Wilson, The Single Family Office
  2. Richard C. Wilson, The Single Family Office (Direct Investments edition)
  3. Richard C. Wilson, Family Office book (Wiley)
  4. Richard C. Wilson, How to Start a Family Office

Related pages

Educational content only. Not investment, tax, legal or securities advice. Quotes are verbatim from Richard C. Wilson's own writing, as named in each Sources list. Talk with securities counsel before any offering is made.