Common mistakes family offices make in direct investing
Richard C. Wilson describes in depth due diligence as a process aimed at making sure any fund manager selected or investment made fits the family mandate.[2]It also has to meet the criteria of the family and its chief investment officer.[2]He writes that this work helps avoid frauds, underperforming fund managers, and wild goose chases after poorly structured investment banking deals.[2]A common mistake is to treat direct investing as lighter work than it is, since the responsibility for deep due diligence sits with the investor.[1]Screening is part of the same process. He describes having junior analysts screen the promising deals.[2]He also notes that he and other single family offices created a Direct Investment One Pager Worksheet, which can be printed or sent to team members.[2]
Underestimating monitoring and manager visits
Monitoring does not end once a deal closes. Richard C. Wilson writes that monitoring direct investments, real estate, and private equity funds is part of total portfolio monitoring.[2]He adds that direct investments rarely require daily attention, unless the family office has employed a Chief Direct Investment Officer.[2]Rarely daily does not mean never.[2]His Family Office book also covers how family offices check fund managers. Family offices often prefer to meet at the fund manager's office, so that things look and feel professional and institutional.[3]The goal is to learn that a manager is more than a confident voice on the phone and a polished slide presentation.[3]Many family offices are stretched thin. Flying to distant cities to visit a manager who may or may not receive capital is often not practical.[3]Some family offices in the United States and Europe do not look at global fund managers as a rule.[3]Larger family offices often hire an institutional consulting firm to evaluate managers and conduct the on site visits.[3]
Misreading how coinvestment works
Richard C. Wilson defines coinvesting as an investor, often an institutional one, placing capital alongside an investment fund into a target investment, rather than through the fund.[4]In one example, a private equity fund grants coinvestment rights to a single family office, which then invests directly alongside the fund instead of as a traditional limited partner.[4]He separates this from a club deal, which is a group of active investors that team up, while a coinvestment is sourced by the general partner or lead investor.[4]He also describes why each side cares. General partners have resisted coinvestment rights because they add complexity to the fund.[4]The general partner gives up capital that would have been invested under the standard fund vehicle.[4]Other limited partners are also more likely to ask for similar arrangements.[4]Family offices want the rights because they hope to reduce overall fees and manage more investments internally.[4]Missing either side of this picture is an easy mistake.[4]
Planning the exit too late and ignoring the family's edge
Richard C. Wilson writes that a seller can work with financial experts to improve the balance sheet and make sure the corporate structure is appropriate.[4]He also describes creating an auction like environment by having multiple competing interested buyers.[4]A buyer may want a company for its synergies, or to block competitors from entering a market or growing stronger.[4]Skilled negotiation and deal structuring can greatly increase the value received in a sale, and investment bankers or a merchant bank often help.[4]In his Family Office book, he notes that a family office's competitive advantage is often the amount of capital it controls.[3]Family offices use that capital to seek exclusive access to deals, preferred terms, discounted management fees, or ownership stakes.[3]He also writes that when returns are not there, a single family office may think seriously about finding someone else, often internally, to invest the money.[1]
Steps you can take
- Write down the family mandate and the criteria of the family and its chief investment officer before reviewing any deal.
- Have junior analysts screen promising deals before senior people spend time on them.
- Use a one page direct investment worksheet to record each opportunity in the same format.
- Set a monitoring routine for direct investments, even if daily attention is not needed.
- Meet fund managers at their offices when possible, or use a consulting firm for distant on site visits.
- Learn why general partners resist coinvestment rights and why family offices want them.
- Prepare for an exit early by reviewing the balance sheet, the corporate structure, and the list of possible buyers.
This is critical to avoid frauds, underperforming fund managers and wild goose chases running after poorly structured investment banking deals.
Questions people ask next
Why is due diligence stressed so often in direct investing?
Richard C. Wilson writes that direct investing carries the risk and responsibility of deep due diligence.[1]He also says a thorough process helps avoid frauds, underperforming fund managers, and poorly structured deals.[2]
What is coinvesting?
Richard C. Wilson defines it as an investor placing capital alongside an investment fund into a target investment, rather than through the fund.[4]A family office might receive such a right from a private equity fund and invest directly next to it.[4]
How do family offices check fund managers who are far away?
Richard C. Wilson writes that many family offices are stretched thin, so long trips for on site visits are often impractical.[3]Some skip global managers as a rule, and larger ones often hire an institutional consulting firm to conduct the visits.[3]
Sources
- Richard C. Wilson, The Single Family Office
- Richard C. Wilson, How to Start a Family Office
- Richard C. Wilson, Family Office book (Wiley)
- Richard C. Wilson, The Single Family Office (Direct Investments edition)
Related pages
- What mistakes do family offices make when investing?
- How do family offices run due diligence on direct deals?
- Why do family offices separate direct deals from fund commitments?
- How do family offices source direct investments?
- Family office direct investing
Educational content only. Not investment, tax, legal or securities advice. Quotes are verbatim from Richard C. Wilson's own writing, as named in each Sources list. Talk with securities counsel before any offering is made.