Text or WhatsApp (808) 600-9260Richard@FamilyOffices.com

Structure trumps strategy

Richard C. Wilson uses this talk to argue that the structure of a deal often matters as much as, or more than, the strategy. An average strategy with a strong structure can become an excellent deal, he says, and a strong deal with a poor structure can be made horrible for the other side. Newly liquid investors, in his experience, often accept an offering as written and rarely negotiate the structure. The importance of it usually becomes clear after seven or ten years of putting out capital.

What stood out

  1. A first-loss position can make investors more comfortable. He describes a deal he was looking to close the following Tuesday, a chokepoint asset in an investor niche. Investors would get all of their money back first on a sale, then he would get his back, so he would be the first to take a loss. He does that, he says, to show that if the deal goes poorly, he feels the pain first.
  1. Tax terms can change what both sides will accept. In another example, 100 percent bonus depreciation in year one produced a $300,000 negative K-1 on a $300,000 check, which let them offer a 1.5 times return over five to seven years instead of 2 times, while the investor still saw something like a 2.3 times result after the tax benefit. He is not a CPA and tells people not to act on comments from an event without advice that fits their situation.
  1. Some deals pay investors from gross revenue, not from profits. He says they usually structure monthly or quarterly gross revenue royalties, and that they had done a dozen of those deals in operating businesses and some real estate. Investors like the income check even if a quarter is not profitable. This does not work, he says, for a pre-revenue startup unless the royalty is delayed, which is risky.
  1. Membership classes and collateral can speed a raise. Different classes, or a note versus equity, can change who receives depreciation, which belongs with a CPA. On a healthcare deal, he describes writing in that if the business shut down, insurance receivables for two or three months would go to investors first. If you are confident the business will not fail, he asks, what is the real cost of making investors more comfortable? He also tells people to avoid personal guarantees and recourse bank loans.

In his words

"many times the structure of a deal matters as much if not more than the strategy."

Richard C. Wilson, Structure Trumps Strategy

"trying to structure it so it protects the investor makes you able to raise capital faster."

Richard C. Wilson, Structure Trumps Strategy

From Richard C. Wilson's Centimillionaire Strategies YouTube channel: Structure Trumps Strategy. Quotes come from the video captions. Figures and examples are the speaker's own, from the talk.

Related pages

Educational content only. Not investment, tax, legal or securities advice. Quotes are verbatim from Richard C. Wilson's own writing, as named in each Sources list. Talk with securities counsel before any offering is made.