How to spot a process gap in your own raise
Richard C. Wilson describes the way family offices review a fund as a set of steps.[2]In one step, the fund manager or an investor relations professional walks the family office through the presentation and answers questions.[1]The manager can also elaborate on points that interest the family office.[1]Wilson writes that most pitch books and teasers are carefully prepared to present the fund in a favorable light.[2]The call gives savvy family office CIOs and analysts a chance to poke holes in the strategy and performance.[2]After these calls, family offices can form a better opinion of the investment and a sense of how the fund manager operates.[2]Wilson writes that these calls are usually at least half an hour long.[1]Wilson has joined many that ran for hours, although active single family offices usually try to limit calls as much as possible.[1]
Gaps between what is claimed and what is done
Wilson's Family Office book points to how consistent a fund's investment and risk management processes are.[3]When a manager does not follow the parameters or process the manager set out or claimed to follow, the result is often called style drift.[3]Style drift often leads a family office to decide not to invest.[3]The same book says family offices are more sophisticated than high net worth individuals but do not have the deep analyst teams that large institutions such as pension funds often have.[3]A manager's process therefore has to be clear enough that an analyst or chief investment officer who does not review managers full time can follow it.[3]If the family office does not understand the investment thesis, the edge in the marketplace, or the link between the team and its research, portfolio construction methods and expertise, the family office may move on.[3]That can happen before a full due diligence review is even completed.[3]
Where the due diligence stage can stall
Wilson writes that full due diligence begins once a family office is seriously considering an investment.[2]The main document is the due diligence questionnaire, also called the DDQ.[2]It is a list of questions running anywhere from 50 to 200 and covering many areas.[2]This stage can sometimes slow momentum toward a deal because both sides have to work through the details.[2]A family office executive Richard C. Wilson interviewed said an industry standard DDQ often works well.[3]That executive added that a larger, highly institutionalized family office with specific investment criteria may define its own.[3]The same executive tries to avoid relying too heavily on checking the box.[3]A checklist still matters, for example confirming that the named independent third party administrator is the actual administrator.[3]Other points call for gut checking.[3]Wilson also lists poor due diligence as a common mistake in direct investing.[2]Many single family offices have small teams and limited time, which can lead to rushed review or reliance on third parties who are stretched thin.[2]Wilson sets a floor of 40 hours of due diligence, background checks and reference checks for most single family offices.[2]
Why the review is ongoing and varied
Wilson notes that direct investing comes with the risk and responsibility of deep due diligence and of maintenance and monitoring of the portfolio.[2]Actively managed funds almost always make up a significant part of a single family office portfolio.[1]Wilson's chapter on fund manager selection focuses on alternative funds such as hedge funds, private equity and other private fund vehicles.[1]Family office portfolios also differ by the generation of the family, risk appetite, the industry where the money was made, family priorities and location.[1]Because of these differences, a capital raiser can expect questions to vary from one investor to the next.[1]
Steps you can take
- Write out your investment process in plain steps that an analyst who reviews managers part time can follow.
- Compare what your materials claim with what you actually do, and note any drift.
- List the holes an analyst might poke in your strategy and performance before the first call.
- Prepare answers to a standard DDQ before one arrives.
- Check facts such as the named administrator the way a checklist would.
- Plan time for a long questionnaire so momentum does not stall.
- Ask a colleague to play the family office and note where questions go unanswered.
Family offices will be able to form a better opinion of the investment after engaging in these calls and get a sense for how the fund manager operates.
Questions people ask next
What is style drift?
Style drift is when a manager does not follow the investment parameters or process the manager set out or claimed to follow.[3]It often leads a family office to decide not to invest.[3]
What is a DDQ?
The DDQ is the due diligence questionnaire, the primary document investors use in full due diligence, and it runs anywhere from 50 to 200 questions.[2]This stage can sometimes slow momentum toward a deal.[2]
Why might a family office stop reviewing a fund early?
If the family office does not understand the thesis, the edge in the marketplace, or how the team connects to its research and expertise, it may move on.[3]Family offices often lack the deep analyst teams that large institutions have.[3]
Sources
- Richard C. Wilson, The Single Family Office (Direct Investments edition)
- Richard C. Wilson, The Single Family Office
- Richard C. Wilson, Family Office book (Wiley)
Related pages
- Should a placement agent replace your own raise process?
- A five-step raise process
- How to document process so the next raise is easier
- How to explain your process when an investor asks how you raise
- How do single family offices fit a capital raise?
Educational content only. Not investment, tax, legal or securities advice. Quotes are verbatim from Richard C. Wilson's own writing, as named in each Sources list. Talk with securities counsel before any offering is made.