How to read a private deal memo as a family office professional
Richard C. Wilson writes that first round screening details deserve careful thought. The aim is to weed out 80% or more of the deals being pitched[1]. A head of direct investments, an analyst, or a portfolio manager can help take a first cut at deals[1]. Wilson also describes having junior analysts screen the promising deals[2]. He describes a table of criteria for evaluating a team, an asset, or a company[1]. He calls these criteria high level filtering items and says they are not exhaustive[1]. Customized for the investor and the team, they can save time and money in due diligence fees, travel, and team resources[1]. He also writes that not all deal flow is created equal, and that everyone wants a more focused and qualified deal flow[1].
Check fit with the mandate
Wilson describes a due diligence process aimed at making sure any fund manager selected or any investment made fits within the family mandate[2]. The process also checks the criteria of the family and its CIO[2]. He calls this critical for avoiding frauds, underperforming fund managers, and wild goose chases after poorly structured investment banking deals[2]. A direct investment comes with the risk and responsibility of deep due diligence and monitoring of the portfolio[3]. A family office executive Richard C. Wilson interviewed described a formal investment committee with a regular agenda[4]. In that setup, a fund investment department prepares due diligence packages and recommendations for the committee to discuss and decide[4].
Read the structure and the terms
Some deals come with co-investment. Wilson defines it as a limited partner investing directly with a general partner in a company, both through the fund and directly[5]. The investor then holds two stakes in the company, one through the fund and one directly[3]. Co-investment rights are one concession fund managers offer to encourage capital commitments to a fund[3]. Wilson lists reasons general partners have resisted co-investment rights[5]. The right adds a layer of complexity to the fund, and the general partner gives up capital that would have gone through the standard fund vehicle[5]. Other limited partners are also more likely to ask for similar arrangements[5]. On the other side, he writes that LPs hope to use co-investments to reduce overall fees on private equity investments and to manage more investments internally[5]. Wilson also notes that complete buyouts by family offices are typically financed with debt to increase the return on investment and reduce the equity at stake in any one buyout[3]. He adds that family offices work with fund managers in many ways, and often seek exclusive access to deals, preferred terms, discounted management fees, or ownership stakes[4].
Plan for what comes after the decision
Wilson writes that monitoring direct investments, real estate, and private equity funds is part of total portfolio monitoring[2]. Direct investments rarely require daily attention, unless the family office has a Chief Direct Investment Officer to cover that area[2]. He also lists speaking with other family offices and investors who have similar portfolios and challenges as part of the work[2].
Steps you can take
- Write down your own first round screening criteria before you open the memo.
- Ask an analyst or head of direct investments to take a first cut at the deal.
- Check the deal against the family mandate and the criteria of the family and its CIO.
- Note whether the memo describes a fund stake, a direct stake, or both through co-investment.
- List the terms the memo offers, such as fees and co-investment rights, and compare them with your needs.
- Package your due diligence findings for an investment committee discussion.
- Plan how the investment would be monitored after the decision.
One truth I have found is that not all deal flow is created equal, and nobody wants just lots of investment pitches of any quality or location.
Questions people ask next
What is co-investment?
Wilson defines it as a limited partner investing directly with a general partner in a company, both through the fund and directly[5]. The investor ends up with two stakes in the same company[3].
Who can help with the first screen of a deal?
Wilson writes that a head of direct investments, an analyst, or a portfolio manager can help take a first cut at deals[1]. He also describes junior analysts screening the promising deals[2].
Why does due diligence matter for a family office?
Wilson describes due diligence as a way to check that a fund manager or investment fits the family mandate[2]. He says it helps avoid frauds, underperforming fund managers, and poorly structured investment banking deals[2].
Sources
- Richard C. Wilson, Centimillionaire Strategies
- Richard C. Wilson, How to Start a Family Office
- Richard C. Wilson, The Single Family Office
- Richard C. Wilson, Family Office book (Wiley)
- Richard C. Wilson, The Single Family Office (Direct Investments edition)
Related pages
- How should a new professional read a private deal memo?
- How to read an investment memo as family office staff
- What is private equity in a family office context?
- How do family offices decide to pass on a private deal?
- How do family offices keep ethics in view on a private deal?
Educational content only. Not investment, tax, legal or securities advice. Quotes are verbatim from Richard C. Wilson's own writing, as named in each Sources list. Talk with securities counsel before any offering is made.