How family offices treat side letters and special terms
Richard C. Wilson describes a period when many hedge funds and private equity firms were loath to accommodate even large institutional investors.[2]In that period, GPs routinely dismissed LP requests for improved terms, lower fees, and greater flexibility in their investments.[2]He then describes a shift. Many GPs began to reconsider their earlier intransigence because investors held more negotiating strength over terms, fees, and structure.[1]He also describes a time when many funds collapsed or recorded double-digit losses, which left hedge funds and private equity funds eager to win over limited partners.[2]
Co-investment rights as a special term
Wilson writes that co-investment rights are one of the concessions fund managers offer to institutional investors as an inducement for committing capital to a fund.[1]By offering them, a general partner can often persuade reluctant investors to allocate to a fund.[1]The investor commits capital as a traditional limited partner and also keeps the right to co-invest directly alongside the fund.[1]That gives the investor two stakes in the company. One comes through the fund and the other comes directly.[1]Wilson defines co-investing as an investor, often an institutional investor with substantial investable capital, allocating capital alongside a fund to a target investment rather than through the fund.[2]His example is a private equity fund that grants co-investment rights to a single family office. If the fund is taking a company private for $10 billion, it may carve out a $500 million piece for the family office to invest directly.[2]
Reading the fine print
Wilson writes that co-investments are typically structured by an attorney or investment professional with experience in these agreements.[1]The fund manager will often have more experience structuring co-investments and negotiating terms. So seemingly minor clauses and conditions can have a big impact on the investment.[1]He gives examples. An investor may push for terms that let the LP thoroughly review the potential co-investment and have proper time to evaluate the due diligence documents the fund itself relies on.[1]The fund may also make explicit in the side letter or LPA that the investor assumes responsibility for the investment and cannot blame the GP if it turns out poorly, barring fraud or similar extraordinary failures.[1]Because an attorney or investment professional often structures these agreements, family offices often talk with securities counsel about them.[1]In negotiations, Wilson writes that the LP should make clear the desired level of involvement in the company. The LP should also make clear how the investment will be structured, either as a co-investment through the fund or as a direct investment.[1]
Deciding what control to keep
In Centimillionaire Strategies, Wilson describes three areas of investment that are typically treated separately from each other. They differ in the level of control the family requires and in the amount of risk or the investment goals for that part of the portfolio.[3]He writes that the most important question is which of six levels of potential control a family wants to retain for each area.[3]He suggests an exercise. A family drafts its approach to the three areas and the level of control it may want for each, using a short worksheet table.[3]Wilson also writes that first-round screening details can weed out 80% or more of the deals being pitched.[3]Clear control preferences and clear screening both help a family office decide which terms matter before a negotiation begins.[3]
Steps you can take
- Read the side letter and the fund agreement together, line by line.
- Mark small clauses and conditions that could have a big impact on the investment.
- Ask for enough time to review the due diligence documents the fund relies on.
- Check who carries responsibility if the investment turns out poorly.
- State the desired level of involvement and how the investment will be structured.
- Decide which level of control the family wants for each area of the portfolio.
- Talk with securities counsel before agreeing to special terms.
Co-investment rights are one of the concessions offered by fund managers to institutional investors as an inducement for committing capital to a fund. By offering co-investment rights, a general partner can often persuade reticent investors to allocate to a fund.
Questions people ask next
What is a co-investment right?
It lets an investor commit capital to a fund as a traditional limited partner and also invest directly alongside the fund.[1]
Why might a fund manager offer special terms?
Wilson writes that co-investment rights are a concession offered to institutional investors as an inducement for committing capital to a fund.[1]A general partner can often persuade reluctant investors to allocate by offering them.[1]
Who usually structures a co-investment agreement?
Wilson writes that an attorney or investment professional with experience in these agreements typically structures them.[1]The fund manager will often have more experience than the investor.[1]
Sources
- Richard C. Wilson, The Single Family Office
- Richard C. Wilson, The Single Family Office (Direct Investments edition)
- Richard C. Wilson, Centimillionaire Strategies
Related pages
- How family offices treat confidential information in private deals
- How do single family offices fit a capital raise?
- What should a capital raiser learn about single family offices?
- How do family offices differ from institutional investors?
- How do family offices run due diligence on direct deals?
Educational content only. Not investment, tax, legal or securities advice. Quotes are verbatim from Richard C. Wilson's own writing, as named in each Sources list. Talk with securities counsel before any offering is made.